Monday, January 20, 2025

All the Colors of the Dark by Chris Whitaker

Amy  


mystery

After a young teen thwarts the attack of a classmate, he is abducted in her place. His best friend won’t rest or relent in her search to find him.

As usual, I didn’t read the book summary before beginning All the Colors of the Dark for my book club. However, not far into this highly rated novel, I feared I would be  abandoning it. I truly cannot enjoy child abduction stories. It’s too awful for me to contemplate. But I persevered because of all the rave reviews and for the sake of book club discussion.

Truly, it was a heartbreaking novel. So much sadness, disadvantage, poor choice-making, and desperation. Did it hold my attention? Absolutely, although I often kept listening while filled with dread and wanting to stop. Were there sections and characters that held hope and positivity? Definitely. But this book was still an unpleasant, sorrowful experience for me until about the 2/3 mark. The main characters were so flawed and/or damaged. Some were obsessed. Some were misguided. Some were neglected. But they all suffered. Sure, I like a story where characters have both light and dark sides. But this one was lopsided with so much heartache.

The last third of the novel is the best part. The last quarter was unputdownable which, I suspect, is the reason so many people think this is a stellar novel. I’m still not sure I’m glad I read this novel but the ending made it worthwhile. All the Colors of the Dark is going to haunt me for a very long time.

The best parts of the story involved the coincidences. Like the other Chris Whitaker novel I’ve read, We Begin at the End, the story included a policeman full of heart in a small town, children in crisis, inept parental figures, a broken justice system, hard knocks, characters with the capacity for love but the incapacity to show it. It was a tale both tragic and heartwarming.

Edoardo Ballerini narrated the audiobook and he is one of my favorites. He did his usual great job with voice acting and vocal repertoire. I’ll give him an A.

No comments:

Post a Comment