Amy
Lynnie
young adult, romance
In
Everything, Everything,
Nicola Yoon creates a story around a girl with an all-consuming disease and her desire to live a bigger, maybe even different life. Isolated from the world, Maddie Whitier, must decide whether the life she wants to lead and the possibility of love is worth dying for.
Amy's Review
I enjoyed this one despite figuring that the ending had to go the way it did. I even enjoyed it despite the fact that, aside from the protagonist’s situation (she’s a girl with SCID—a “bubble girl”), it’s just a contemporary teenage romance novel. It was well done, entertaining, full of heart, and even fun. I listened to the majority of the novel via audiobook but had won a signed hardcopy from First in Line back in January. So, when I got so close to the end and really wanted to get closure, I pulled out the book to finish it off. While the audiobook narration was wonderful, the book itself is a treasure with the cute illustrations and artistic devices in the book. I would have completely missed that aspect if I’d only listened to the audiobook. And, it’s even more special to learn that the illustrator is the author’s husband! I love that!
In summary, for a teen romance, it was great. Sure, some parts were not realistic (which I cannot describe here without spoilers) but it was all in good fun and I let myself enjoy it.
Lynnie's Review
I'm torn about Everything, Everything as it was equal parts interesting and frustrating.
Maddie
was an interesting character, suffering from a severe immune deficiency
that forces her to live in a sterilized home with very few people
allowed to visit. She is smart, engaging, a voracious reader and
utterly isolated from the real world that exists outside her home.
It's hard to review this book without giving away too much, but while some people have felt this is a book about love, friendship, and learning to accept people for who they are (& that's definitely in this book), I felt this was a book about control; having it, losing it, and learning to live with the consequences of it.
Overall it's a quick and entertaining book.