Amy 
fiction
June is an aspiring writer who has maintained a strained
friendship with her old college friend, Athena, an extremely popular,
successful novelist. Athena has everything June wants. One night, as they are
having a drunken pancake eating contest (yes, really), Athena chokes and dies. June
takes the publicly unknown manuscript Athena has just completed, makes edits, and sells the novel as her own creation to great acclaim. Since June is
white, she faces public scrutiny for writing about WWI Chinese Labor Corps
members and is accused of cultural appropriation. She also strenuously denies
accusations of stealing the book from Athena.
The only other novel I’d read by R.F. Kuang was an extremely
violent fantasy full of terrible things being done to people. So I was
interested to read something entirely different by her. However, I can
definitely still see the amoral, self-absorbed tendencies in these characters
that existed within The Poppy War’s characters. Kuang seems to have an affinity
for women who see themselves as wronged and, as a result, feel they have
license to do bad things.
It is no wonder why June had no friends and was not even
close with her family. Sure, she had experienced some traumas before the events
of this novel, but the author never drew a straight line between those events
and the unprincipled, dishonest, and misguided person she had become. Her
motivations seemed to be greed and seeking attention.
June does bad things and deals with the fallout of those
choices. In fact, all of her troubles were caused by her own actions. June wasn’t
always the most reliable or forthright narrator and her excuses and attempts to
spin the narrative didn’t help me like her. Of course, this was the author’s
intent but June was such an unlikeable person that I could never really care
how her life turned out. She was insecure, guilty, and self-delusional. The sad
thing was that she could be very creative when she had to talk her way out of
trouble yet she did not seem to be able to come up with any good ideas for a
novel herself.
Yellowface touched on some important contemporary topics and
controversies being faced within the writing industry such as general
publishing obstacles, cultural exploitation, racism, social media
reviews/attention, the author's share of profits, writer’s block, and dealing
with fickle celebrity status. But, despite these provoking subjects which
interested me, I kept looking to see how much of the novel remained because I was hoping it would end soon. I could not get behind June and there was
no one who would come out better or improved within this plot. This novel was
basically a detailed train wreck told by someone in whose head I wished I
didn’t have to stay for too long. I got and appreciated the messages Kuang was
passing to the reader, I just didn’t love the experience of living this lengthy
story from June’s perspective.
I don’t know whether I’ll read any more books by Kuang. I see her talent as a writer but
I just don’t like reading about all the tarnished characters.
The audiobook was narrated by Helen Laser. She did a good job overall. She had some
different voices up her sleeve and she did June’s snark really well. I’ll give her an A-.