Amy 
Lynnie 
romantasy, fantasy, romance
Following the events of Fourth Wing, Violet must survive another year at Basgiath war college while Xaden begins his service as a lieutenant guarding Navarre. As secrets are revealed, will their bond and their dragons be enough to see them through the year?
We don't normally make separate posts about sequels. We tend to just add the sequels' reviews to the posts for the original books in the series. This is because there aren't usually too many new things to say about sequels that differ from our comments about the original novels. But we both had a lot to say about this sequel so it warrants its own blog post.
Amy's Review
Wow.
WOW!
This really long novel, the
second in The Empyrean series, was one of the most entertaining and
engrossing novels I’ve read in a while. I listened to the Iron Flame
audiobook and it was 28 hours long! Rebecca Yarros is an experienced
romance author but I believe this series is her first foray into fantasy
and I’m, frankly, stunned at how much I loved it! I’ll have to check
out more of her novels.
This sequel picked up right where Fourth
Wing left off. The quick pace of the story was never-ending, continually
moving somewhere, and exciting. It kept me glued to the story and I
would find myself creating opportunities to listen. Violet was a
kick-ass heroine, there was a particularly evil new villain, Violet's relationship with Xaden seemed more balanced, all the old friends were
there in addition to new ones, and we learned more about the
dragons. Iron Flame was one of those rare and special second novels in a
series that was better than the first!
I’m so happy that Yarros
didn’t split this novel into two novels, which would have been very easy
to do. There was even the perfect spot to do it. Rather, she packed
this story full of fun and adventure! There were some rough sections in
terms of cruelty and violence. I did have to take a few breaks when I
was dreading what was to come. But I always dove back in to find out
what would happen next. I have grown to really care what happens to
these characters.
Was it a perfect novel? No. There were
definitely some holes, ridiculous character decisions that were only made to add
drama, and Yarros made some convenient changes to “the rules” of
Violet’s world along the way. For example, Andarna was supposed to be
such a secret but everyone in Violet’s inner circle in this book knew
everything that Violet knew about Andarna without any fanfare or anger
from the dragons. Still,
it was a great tale overall and I really loved it. I’ll definitely
read it whenever it’s released.
The main audiobook narrator was
Rebecca Soler who I’ve heard several times before reading other novels.
She’s always good. However, for this novel, I wish she’d used more
differentiation between Violet’s and Xaden’s voices because dialogues
were often hard to follow. Also, she gave the listener no clues to tell
us when Violet’s and Xaden’s conversations were via their connection
versus out loud. I feel that made me miss some subtleties in the story.
While she had a little repertoire of different voices, I really wished
for more. I’ll give her a A- because she did a lot of good vocal acting
with some crazy source material which was often frenetically paced. She
made it exciting and not silly. Teddy Hamilton narrated the very end
from Xaden’s point of view and he was excellent. I hope we hear more
from Xaden’s point of view in future novels and that Hamilton narrates. I
don’t know if Hamilton has a good vocal repertoire or not from this
short narration, but I love his voice and his voice acting. It was
perfect. A solid A for his small part.
Lynnie's Review
So, I feel a bit like the Empyrean party pooper,
because everyone else loves these books. Similar to my feelings for
Fourth Wing, I DID enjoy Iron Flame overall. There is a lot to enjoy
within its pages - excellent world building, a strong heroine, dragons
(!), family, found family, love, adventure, sacrifice, and betrayal...
And yet.
The
relationship between Violet and Xaden is still completely unhealthy.
They act every bit of their 20-something years old — immature, selfish,
co-dependent, possessive, unable to have a normal conversation, playing
games instead of just being honest with one another and yet completely
obsessed with each other. Possibly more disturbing, they are willing to
sacrifice anyone and anything including their entire society or
themselves for each other; I found them infuriating.
I also
found Violet somewhat tiresome during her forced separation from Xaden
during Part 1. However, I really enjoyed getting to know the marked ones
better as she spent more time with them and we got to know other
members of the squad. Then, the second half of the book brought about a
complete shift in tone and other things to enjoy and new frustrations.
I
was fascinated and horrified by Delores Umbridge... oops, sorry... Vice
Commandant Varrish. I listened to the audiobook of Iron Flame and the
voice acting during some of the pivotal scenes with Varrish and Violet
were some of the most outstanding and heartbreaking of the book. I'm
sure they were equally gripping while reading but Rebecca Soler's voice
acting during those scenes- wow!
I was not surprised by the ending. After all,
Yarros spends much of the novel telling you that it's coming. I guess
the next novel is expected in November and I've heard there will be five
books in the series so there is plenty of time for Yarros to figure out
how to get the squad out of this particularly trouble. Time will tell.
Interestingly,
I think I like the secondary characters more than I like Violet and
Xaden. Regardless of my frustrations, I do want to know what happens
next. I like the cast of characters and want to know how things work out
for them.
As with the first book, I also enjoyed the one chapter
that Teddy Hamilton narrated as Xaden. As I said after Fourth Wing, I
would love to hear more chapters from his perspective, not just because I
think Hamilton has a lovely voice, but because I think the change in
perspective could really add something new to the story.